If you are diving into the high-end world of "Super Clone" Rolex watches, you have likely hit a fork in the road: VS Factory (VSF) or Clean Factory (CF)?
These two manufacturers are the titans of the 1:1 super clone watches industry. But choosing between them isn’t about which is "better"—it’s about what you value more: The Engine (Movement) or The Body (Case & Bezel).
This guide breaks down the rivalry, compares their flagship models (Submariner, GMT-Master II, Datejust), and demystifies the confusing V1, V2, and V3 version history.
The Core Philosophy: Inside vs. Outside
Before looking at specific models, you must understand the DNA of each factory.
VS Factory (The Engineers)
VSF is famous for one thing: Proprietary Movements.
They revolutionized the market by partnering with the Dandong movement factory to create the VS3135 and VS3235 movements. These are true clones, meaning they accept genuine Rolex parts and possess the correct 70+ hour power reserve.
Strengths: Best movements in the game, superior sapphire crystals (better clarity), and excellent "out of the box" feel.
Weaknesses: Case shapes (especially lugs) are sometimes slightly thinner or less accurate than Clean.
Clean Factory (The Artists)
Clean Factory started as a supplier of ceramic bezels (the "Clean Bezel") before making full watches. Their focus is aesthetics.
Strengths: Best ceramic bezels (color and action), superior case shaping (lugs match genuine perfectly), and high-quality 904L steel finishing.
Weaknesses: Often used inferior movements (Shanghai 3235) with lower power reserves (40 hours) in the past, though they are now upgrading. Crystals can sometimes have a "milky" white ring at the edge.
Model Showdown: Which Factory Wins?
1. The Submariner (116610 & 126610)
Winner: VS Factory (VSF)
The VSF Edge: The Submariner is VSF’s crown jewel. Their VS3235 movement is stable, winds like butter, and holds a 72-hour charge. Their crystal clarity is unmatched, offering the true "black hole" effect on the date window.
The Clean Alternative: Clean makes a better case. If you measure the lugs with calipers, Clean is closer to Rolex. However, their movement (often the VR3235 or Shanghai 3235) feels grittier and lacks the long power reserve.
Verdict: Buy VSF for the movement and crystal. Buy Clean only if you plan to swap the crystal and movement later.
2. The GMT-Master II (Pepsi, Batgirl, Sprite)
Winner: Clean Factory (Mostly)
The Clean Edge: For years, Clean held the exclusive contract for the DD3285 movement (the correct clone movement for GMTs). Furthermore, their Pepsi (Red/Blue) ceramic bezel is the closest to genuine red; others often look purple or brown.
The VSF Challenge: VSF recently released their own GMTs with the DD3285. They are excellent, but Clean still holds the edge on the bezel colors, especially for the Pepsi.
Verdict: Stick with Clean Factory for the Pepsi (V3). For the Batgirl/Batman (Black/Blue), VSF and Clean are tied.
3. The Datejust 41mm
Winner: Tie (Depends on Preference)
VSF: Best crystal and movement. The Datejust relies heavily on the sparkle of the crystal and the smooth sweep of the hand, which VSF nails. However, their lugs are slightly "skinny."
Clean: Best case shape. The lugs have the correct curvature and thickness. If you have a small wrist, the Clean case sits better.
Verdict: If you want a reliable daily wearer, go VSF. If you are obsessed with case accuracy, go Clean (and maybe upgrade the crystal).
A side-by-side comparison of the two leading manufacturers. Whether you are looking for the best Submariner movement or the most accurate Daytona case, use this guide to choose the right factory.
Comparison Breakdown: Features, Movement, and Accuracy
Feature
VS Factory (VSF)
Clean Factory (CF)
Best For
Submariner, Datejust, Omega
GMT-Master II, Daytona
Movement
10/10 (Dandong VS3235 - 72hr reserve)
8/10 (Shanghai 3235 or Dandong 3285)
Crystal Clarity
10/10 (Clear, Black Hole effect)
8/10 (Good, but sometimes milky)
Case Accuracy
8/10 (Lugs can be slim)
10/10 (Near perfect measurements)
Bezel Quality
9/10 (Great action)
10/10 (Best color accuracy)
Decoding the Versions: V1 vs. V2 vs. V3
Factories release "Versions" to fix flaws reported by buyers. Here is the cheat sheet for the current market.
VS Factory Versions
V1: The VSF Rolex super clone watches versions V1 launch. Great movements but often had weak "rehaut" (inner ring) engravings and standard bracelets.
V2: Fixed the rehaut polishing and improved the case geometry.
V3 (Current Standard): Usually refers to the VS3235 movement update. V3 models have reinforced movement parts (like the reverser wheel) to prevent breaking. On the Submariner "Starbucks" (Green bezel), V3 corrected the green tone to match the 2023 genuine update (Mk2 bezel).
Clean Factory Versions (Crucial for GMTs)
V1: Good cases, but bad crystals (milky white gasket) and incorrect bezel colors (Pepsi looked fake red).
V2: Fixed the "milky gasket" issue on the crystal.
V3 (The Pepsi Update): This is the most famous update. Clean V3 Pepsi bezels react to UV light exactly like genuine Rolex ceramic (turning a specific pinkish-red). This version also standardized the use of the superior Dandong 3285 movement in their GMT line.
Final Verdict: Which one should you buy?
Buy VS Factory if: You value a watch that runs perfectly, winds smoothly, and lasts for days off the wrist. If you are buying a Submariner, VSF is the undisputed king.
Buy Clean Factory if: You are a stickler for visual details. If you want the lugs to look exactly right or you are buying a GMT-Master II (Pepsi), Clean is the only way to go.
Read Our Blogs About Technical Details, Factory, Original Vs Super Clone Comparison :- Swiss ETA Watches Gurgaon
This blogs distinguishes between the swiss eta watches available at our website and the japanese AAA first copy watches that you get at a very cheaper price. There is a lot of difference between both of the watches quality & this blog highlights few of them.
This blog provides an ultimate comparison between previous version of swiss eta 2824 vs the latest 1:1 super cloned 3135 movement, mainly used in rolex submariners. We have even compared both of them & came to a conclusion.
In this blog, we compare both the best factories for buying Rolex GMT Master II with swiss ETA 3285 movements . So that you could get a better idea which one to go for.
